St. Bonaventure Catholic School
SCHOOL FACILITIES & ACCOMMODATION ISSUES
 
Administrative and Corporate Services Committee: TCDSB
 
CSAC PRESENTATION
 
Presented by:  Luis Silva
Contributors:
n  Seamus Camlough
n  Sarah O’Dea-Della Rocca
n  Nina Glyn-Williams
n  Hugh Pearson
n  Santoso Sugianto
 
May 10, 2006
 
St. Bonaventure Presentation Plan
  • nBrief History and Background
  • nCurrent Situation
  1. 1.Capacity
  2. 2.Building’s Condition
  3. 3.Demographics
  4. 4.Catholic Presence
  • nOptions
  1. 1.New “Flagship” School
  2. 2.E-Pod Pilot Program &  Upgrades
  3. 3.Addition & Upgrades
  4. 4.Portables & Upgrades
  • nRecommendations
HISTORY AND BACKGROUND
nSt. Bonaventure was built in 1956, adjacent to St. Bonaventure Church with which it has had a strong relationship.  It is about to celebrate it’s 50th anniversary this coming school year.
nBuilt originally to accommodate 130 students but, with 2 major additions over the years, now has capacity for 267.
nCurrent enrollment is 394 students.
n
nSituated in Don Mills - home to a diverse Catholic Community – including public servants, professionals, and leaders of business, commerce, politics and religion.
nThis community demands quality in the education and facilities for our children.  As a result, this area has seen the fastest growth in, and presently the highest concentration of, private schools in Canada.
nUnfortunately, the St. Bonaventure school facilities have not kept pace with the growing needs of its Catholic Community.
 
CURRENT SITUATION:
1. Capacity & Student Accommodation
nPresently 47% over populated - over capacity by 127 students. 
nBuilt for 267 students, it currently houses 394 students through the use of 3 portables.
nAn additional 47% growth projected by 2013. 
nProjected enrollment to rise from current 394 to 582 by 2014 (see Elementary School profile, TCDSB on next page).
nOut of the 3 catholic schools in the area, St. Bonaventure is the only one over capacity and has the highest projected growth.
 
nGymnasium
qcan only hold ½ student population at one time, without violating fire regs.
qIt is also too small to hold any sporting events – low ceiling and approximately ½ size of a standard gym.
nWashrooms. 
qOnly two sets of boys and girls washrooms, all located in the basement, to service the entire 3 floors and all 3 portables of the school.  Will not be enough for projected population of 582 students in 8 years.
 
CAPACITY vs. ENROLLMENT

CURRENT SITUATION
2. Building’s Condition
nObsolete boiler heating system (50 years old);
nObsolete electrical system (inefficient 15 amp system);
nFalling drop-ceiling tiles and crumbling insulation.
nNo air conditioning
nExtreme elevated temperatures in the classrooms on hot, sunny days.
nWater damage to basement classes causing mold growth and rotting plaster(especially important since we have several students in grade 1 alone with severe allergies and epi-pens).
nConsiderable rodent problem with mouse feces in numerous classroom cupboards.
nLack of proper ventilation, resulting in poor air quality.
nThere is no wheelchair access to any part of the building and no floors are at grade to facilitate such access.

 

CURRENT SITUATION
3. Demographics
Don Mills Development and Community
nGrowing influx of young families into the neighborhood (see TCDSB projections)
nCadillac Fairview building new mall and condos/townhouses that will bring additional young families to the neighborhood (these numbers may not be included in the TDCSB projection because the project details are not finalized).
nGrowing number of businesses and head offices moving to the Don Mills increasing profile of the community.
nProximity to Edward Gardens and numerous green spaces provide a unique opportunity for students to enjoy a wide variety of educational activities and environmental programs outside the classroom.

 

CURRENT SITUATION
4. Catholic Presence in Don Mills

nOrder of St. Francis has chosen St. Bonaventure as their flagship for community investment. (see church letter on next page)

nOrder of St. Francis has invested large amounts of capital on the new St. Bonaventure Friary ($2.7 million).

nChurch recently finished construction on a new Parish Centre ($1.1 million).

nOrder of St. Francis sees area as a vibrant and active community.

nParish has grown significantly in young families over the past 5 years.  They foresee much more growth and have invested money now to meet the future need.

nThe bond between church and school has always been strong.  This relationship can only be maintained by investing in a strong catholic education.

 

 FINANCIAL IMPACTS
nThe current situation is resulting in the loss of several sources of funds:
qLoss of student funding in the primary grades as Catholic parents use public school-based day-care facilities and then decide to keep their children in the TDSB system. (e.g. Rippleton and Norman Ingram P.S.)
qLoss of student funding in the intermediate grades as Catholic parents find convenient private schools (i.e. Hawthorne & Northmount) with the upgraded facilities that they want.
qLoss of direct revenue from insufficient facilities to accommodate a before-and-after-school/daycare Centre.
qThe use of portables is a liability to the school board since the Ministry does not directly fund their purchase, operation, nor their maintenance.
 
OPTIONS
1.New “Flagship” School
2.Pilot the E-pod program *
3.Build an Addition *
4.More portables *
5.
 
* Options 2, 3 & 4 would all require the $1.7 million in upgrades and deferred maintenance that is needed for the existing school
 

OPTION 1: NEW “FLAGSHIP” SCHOOL

  • nGreatest expense but most long-term viability.
  • nWill allow the TCDSB to implement the government’s 20 classroom cap without becoming a play-yard filled with portables.
  • nWill allow for future growth as projected.
  • nA Flagship school would be the center for a strong and positive CATHOLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION in the Don Mills community.
  • nAlthough, overall, the TCDSB enrollment is projected to be -2% over the next 15 years, St. Bonaventure’s is projected to be +47% in the next 8 years. (see Chart on slide 5)
  • nWith exposure on Leslie St. (a major artery), the school would be a reminder of the commitment of the TCDSB to excellent catholic education for our leaders of the future.
  • nAllow school to keep its innovative programs, and attract new students with up-to-date facilities.  Such a school would dramatically decrease the loss of students to our public and private counterparts , ensuring needed funding from the Ministry.
  • nA Flagship school will provide the facilities and space for new endeavors such as Best Start, daycare and before-and-after school programs.  These are all revenue driving programs we currently cannot benefit from due to our lack of space.
    nA Flagship school could be built behind the current structure without disrupting on-going classes.
    nA Flagship School would allow for a proper full-sized gym.
    nA Flagship School could have access for the disabled.
    nA Flagship School would have adequate washroom facilities.
    nIf a new school is not built now other capital expenditures will be required at the school in the interim - even though a new school is ultimately inevitable – resulting in wasted funds.

     

OPTION 2:  E-POD PILOT PROGRAM
  • nCheapest solution - cost the same as a new portable.
  • nRequires investment in deferred maintenance ($1.7M).
  • nWould be able to add as many e-pods as extra classrooms required.
  • nAllows for additional washrooms as each e-pod has its own facility- unlike current portables.
  • nThe e-pod can be attached to the school and is considered part of the building thus qualifying for financial assistance from the Ministry – unlike current portables.
  • nIf enough e-pods are attached, a gymnasium can be built in the middle of their structure.
  • nPilot program may prove invaluable to the TCDSB for future growth issues.
  • nStill does not allow for Best Start programs or Daycare within the school.
  • nAccess by the disabled would be limited to classrooms within the e-pod structure.

OPTION 3: BUILD AN ADDITION

  • nSt. Bonaventure has had 2 additions built since its opening;
  • nCould add another addition to the school (coming out in an “L” shape)
  • nAn addition would allow for the future growth of the school;
  • nWould not want to build addition and still require the use of portables, so would need to build 10 more classrooms, larger gym and additional washrooms. 
  • nIn addition to the cost of the new wing, would also have the added expense of the original school upgrades, regarding boiler and new electrical.  ($1.7 million in deferred maintenance to get to 1965 standards).
  • nProbable disruption of classes during its construction;
  • nStill appear as a dated school from the community’s point of view.
  • nWould allow for wheelchair access to that part of the school only.

OPTION 4: Repairs, Renovations & More Portables

  • nComparable cost to e-pods without the aforementioned benefits. 
  • nNo additional washrooms for increased student body.
  • nNo solution for the inadequate gym.
  • nLess money from the Ministry for the portables and their maintenance as they are not considered part of the school building. 
  • nSchool will lose its outside play space.
  • nChildren will still have to go outside through the snow to go to the washroom.
  • nParents will pull their children from St. Bonaventure for the other local, better equipped public or private schools.
  • nThe school will look like an eyesore, shanty town.
  • nThere will still be no room for Best-Start program or Daycare options.
  • nMain structure will continue to fall into disrepair.
  • nNot considered a viable option.

RECOMMENDATIONS

nOur recommendation is to proceed with Option 1: New Flagship School or in the alternative Option 2: Piloting the E-pod Program
nWe do not see Option 4: Additional Portables as a viable solution
nBased on School Board numbers, the school is growing and cannot accommodate the demand in its current situation.
nSt. Bonaventure provides the TCDSB with an opportunity to create a legacy in the Don Mills Catholic community.
nBy providing a Flagship school with modern expanded facilities, it will join the ranks of the Franciscan Friars and the St. Bonaventure Parish who have already invested in this growing Catholic community.
nA Flagship school would entice new and would retain present students -  benefiting the TCDSB via funding and the continuation of Catholic Education.

 

CLOSING REMARKS
nThe CSAC of St. Bonaventure Catholic School would like to thank all the members of our school community for their support.
nWe see this as a collaborative endeavor and have a strong parent group willing to put in the time and effort to come up with a solution. 
nWe offer our resources to come up with creative and innovative solution to our over-population issue. 
nWe are open to discussing all sorts of ventures, including talks with developers for a shared project – new school alongside a seniors condominium/centre etc.
nThank you to the Trustees and Members of the Committee for giving us the opportunity to share with you our vision for a meaningful and powerful partnership in the education of our children, the leaders of tomorrow.